The Pilgrims make the trip to Haughmond as they attempt to book a place in third qualifying round at the second time of asking.
The sides fought out a 1-1 draw at The Jakemans Stadium on Saturday, with Scott Ryan cancelling out Jan Yeomans' opener for the Pilgrims.
The winners will progress to a third qualifying round tie at AFC Mansfield or Rushall Olympic, who also replay on Tuesday evening.
United have no new concerns squad-wise, with midfielder Harry Vince ruled out as he serves the second of a three-match suspension.
Should the replay be level after 90 minutes, the match will progress to extra-time and potentially penalties.
Tuesday's match referee is Robert Massey-Ellis.
UNITED KIT WATCH: (All) Amber.
POSTCODE FOR SAT NAV: SY1 4RQ.
BUSA COACH DEPARTURE: 3.30pm.
LIVE UPDATES: @bostonunited on Twitter.