The Pilgrims led 3-2 with five minutes remaining but Newcastle struck to secure a share of the spoils.
was also on target as United threatened to record their second victory of the New Year.
United led 3-1 at half-time. NUTTELL
had seen his early strike cancelled out by a Newcastle leveller, but the Pilgrims were back in front through BRIERS
added his second goal before the break but Newcastle hit back strongly after half-time and after cutting the deficit early on, the visitors grabbed their equaliser five minutes from time.
Boston (4-4-2): Andy Hewitt
; Niall Delahoy
46), Lewis Sturman
, Jordan Lote, Charlie Rossington
; Jake Platten
, James Reed
, Jake Beauchamp
, Joe Briers
54); Jordan Nuttell
, Charley Sanders
. Sub (not used): Todd Devlin