The Pilgrims will be hoping to avenge their 1-0 home defeat against the Reds on Boxing Day, which was secured courtesy of Reece Styche's sixth minute effort.
Since then, United have drawn 2-2 with leaders Bradford Park Avenue, with Ben Davies and Max Wright on target, while Alfreton were beaten 2-1 by Southport at Haig Avenue.
Gavin Allott and Jay Rollins led the United line on Saturday and could again be pressed into service against Billy Heath's Reds, having not started on Boxing Day.
Tai-Reece Chisholm is also in contention to make his United debut, having completed his loan move to The Jakemans Stadium on the eve of the Bradford encounter.
Last season's corresponding fixture ended 3-2 in the Pilgrims' favour.
Tuesday's match referee is Aaron Bannister, who last took charge of the Pilgrims on October 13 against Blyth Spartans.
POSTCODE FOR SAT NAV: DE55 7FZ.
BUSA COACH DEPARTURE: 12.00pm.
UNITED COLOURS: Amber/Black.
UPDATES: @bostonunited on Twitter.