Nuttell had handed the Pilgrims a half-time lead, but the Pilgrims conceded twice in the second half to lose at the Wast Hills training ground.
Steve Welsh's side were patched up as unavailabilities ravaged their selection options.
NUTTELL scored in the 26th minute, but the Blues hit back with second half strikes after 66 and 72 minutes respectively.
Boston (4-4-2): Marc Hipwell; Niall Delahoy, Jordan Lote, Todd Devlin, Jason Field; Scott Langan, Lewis Sturman, Jake Beauchamp, Aaron Eyett; Jordan Nuttell, Joe Briers.